Discussions
with customers convince Applied Materials to enter single-wafer
wet clean market
A
reluctant Applied Materials decided to enter the wet clean
market after customers convinced the largest chip equipment
manufacturer in the world that it could give them what they
want: much tighter control over 300-mm wafer cleaning at the
front end of the process.
Launched
in June, the Oasis Clean is a modular dry-in/dry-out system
that can clean more than 100 wafers per hour, Applied says.
The tool maker asserts a slew of technological and productivity
benefits for the tool. The single-wafer system features a
megasonic tank that removes particles <0.14 µm without
damaging the substrate. Low oxide/silicon loss is an additional
technological plus claimed for the wet bench. As for productivity,
the four-chamber system reduces cycle time and WIP wafers,
Applied says. As befits its name, the Oasis lowers DI water
use by a factor of 10, according to the company.
Conversations
with customers over a two-year period prompted Applied to
begin seriously considering the prospect of getting involved
in one of the industry's most venerable equipment segments,
says Satheesh Kuppurao, who oversees technical marketing and
strategic technology for the company's wet clean division,
transistor and capacitor group. The equipment manufacturer
began a program at the beginning of 2000 during talks about
RTP and LPCVD equipment, Kuppurao says.
"Increasingly,
we were getting into gate oxide discussions with customers,
all mentioning cleans being a very big part of the front end
of the line," he recalls. "That's how the program got started.
We didn't want to enter this market, actually. We just wanted
to get OEM parts but integrate them with our tools. There
simply wasn't any single-wafer clean out there for the front
end of the line." Applied has been working with a joint development
partner in Europe in developing the Oasis. The company has
since begun collaborating with a Taiwanese partner.
Dainippon
Screen, the Japanese equipment manufacturer, sells a single-wafer
system that it developed with Hitachi, but the Applied marketing
executive claims the system is not as "strong" in FEOL processes
as it is in BEOL processes. Trecenti Technologies, a wafer
foundry, is the first single-wafer 300-mm fab to use the system,
notes Kuppurao. "They saw the benefit of cycle-time reduction,
being a foundry. They could actually turn around chips in
one-third the time."
Dainippon
leads the overall wet-bench market segment with a share of
approximately 35%, according to Dean Freeman, a principal
analyst with Gartner Dataquest. The number of wet-bench players
is fairly extensive and includes suppliers such as SEZ, TEL,
Semitool, Verteq, Akrion, and Mattson. "Dainippon has a [big]
market and didn't want to scavenge its market, with a single-wafer
system," Kuppurao asserts.
 |
FRESH WATER: The Oasis
is Applied Materials' entry into the FEOL wet-clean
market.
|
Revenues
for 300-mm wet cleaning tools are forecast to rise from $671
million in 2003 to approximately $1.4 billion in 2006, Applied
says, citing its own internal forecasts as well as market
data from Gartner Dataquest and VLSI Research. Those same
data show 300-mm single-wafer benches capturing more than
50% of the wet clean market by 2004. In 2001 that figure was
approximately 20%. With the migration to 300-mm fabs picking
up pace, the executive says Applied expects 2004 to offer
"a huge growth opportunity."
One
of the primary reasons is that the market for single-wafer
cleans "has not taken off" at the front end, Kuppurao insists.
"It just hasn't matched batch cleaning in quality and productivity.
That gives us a good entry point." He notes that BEOL cleaning
"is not a market we want to be in, because the chemical producers
make all the money."
The
need for FEOL wet cleans is "kind of like a cell phone," the
technical marketing head suggests. "When you don't have a
cell phone, you don't see the necessity for it. When you have
it, you wonder how you ever got by without it."
As
chipmakers begin ramping up 130-nm processes, challenges that
had remained hidden have begun to surface, Kuppurao says.
Problems for FEOL wet cleans at this technology node encompass
capacitors, contacts, and gates for DRAMs. In logic processes
the issues involve ultrashallow junctions, silicide, and postgate
etch.
Of
all wet clean applications, Applied says approximately 60%
of the market is in FEOL prethermal and poststripping cleans.
The current prethermal cleaning sequence involves three steps:
oxide removal followed by the traditional two-step RCA cleaning
sequence to first remove organics and particles, then metals.
The Oasis sequence shortens the cleaning recipe. The oxide-removal
step is followed by a single-step clean that removes organics,
particles, and metals, Kuppurao says.
After
copper/low-k dielectrics, "the next big challenge is transistor
scaling," he asserts, because 1% of the thickness poses 60%
of the challenges. "We'd been in the gate oxide and front-end
market for a long time promoting single-wafer benefits against
batch furnaces." Your typical wet bench takes 64 minutes to
complete its run. Kuppurao claims the Oasis takes approximately
2 minutes to do the same.
The
depth of an ultrashallow junction is 3035 nm, he says.
Typically, a wet bench can remove approximately 3 nm of the
junction during each batch clean. "If you take this junction
through five cleans you would lose almost half the junction.
To compensate for that, the customer would have to do some
other work [on the wafer]. After awhile you can't afford to
lose those materials, like dopants."
With
its claims for the Oasis's high throughput and small footprint,
Applied believes the industry will shortly begin clamoring
for the system. The bench promises profitability at a time
when fabs have been hit with "a double whammy: 300-mm wafers
and smaller devices," Kuppurao says. The biggest drawback
with single-wafer cleaning has always been matching batch
productivity, he points out. "If they can turn chips faster
in the market and invest less to begin with, profits go up."
The
dry-in/dry-out feature is a major reason for the high throughput
of the four-chamber system, he points out. One wafer from
the loading-port dry goes into the wet clean chamber and,
dried in the same chamber, comes out dry. The tool's robotics
always pick up a spin-dried wafer, never a wet one. This capability
"basically allows us to get more than 100 wafers per hour"
from the system.
Freeman
of Gartner Dataquest thinks the throughput numbers can boost
Applied's chances with the Oasis. "If [100 wafer-per-hour
throughput] is indeed the case, they then start to get cost-competitive
with some of the automated wet benches. Then you have the
additional factor that your day-to-day operating expenses
might be lower than those of a wet bench."
Freeman also likes Applied's chances with Oasis in the wet
clean segment. "The market has been dabbling with a single-wafer
solution for a long time, and everybody's coming up with some
sort of spray version. Some of the [concerns] have been if
you have a spray version, do you get [the wafer] clean enough?"
He says Applied's use of megasonics and fresh single-pass
chemistry with each wafer "has the potential to eliminate
a lot of those problems with respect to resist residue on
the chamber walls, and the potential for particulates to come
back into the chamber.
"It
appears to be a fairly well-thought-out idea," he continues.
"If single-wafer cleaning is going to take off, this tool
has the potential to at least get that market segment kick-started
in a big way."
Other
wet-bench vendors have not been standing still. In June, SEZ
purchased L-Tech, a manufacturer of drying equipment for batch
wafer processes. L-Tech's systems use IPA for drying wafers.
Like Applied, SEZ notes that wet processes are cost-effective
when used with 25- and 50-wafer batches or larger. The trend
toward single-wafer cleaning prompted SEZ to buy L-Tech, which
is also developing several single-wafer cleaning and drying
technologies.
The
Austria-based vendor had been "playing in the back end of
line with spray processes, and they realize there is a huge
market in the front end of the line with automated wet benches,"
Freeman concludes. The acquisition will enable SEZ to "compete
across the board with the likes of Dainippon Screen and TEL."
Add
Applied to that list. Kuppurao says a popular "misimpression"
holds that Applied has no background in wet processes. But,
he points out, the equipment manufacturer has been making
CMP tools for five years. "A little-known fact is we've had
a 'skunk works' program in wet cleaning for a long, long time.
Actually, even 10 years back we had people doing wet chemistry."
The
division marketing and technology head expects to see Oasis
orders coming in over the next six months from logic-device
makers and foundries. Indeed, the company already "has systems
in the booking process right now."
The
rate of market penetration will depend, he says, "on how quickly
300-mm fabs will come onboard. Current plans call for his
division to focus only on those customers that can provide
the supplier with technical feedback. This list includes manufacturers
of ASICs, microprocessors, and DRAMs, as well as foundry companies.